Nowadays, homeowners have plenty of options for countertop materials. However, butcher blocks and granite are tough competitors in this list. Granite is popular for its aesthetic and durability, whereas butcher block counters are easy to restore and offer your kitchen a classic look.
Want to buy a brand new countertop for your kitchen, but can’t decide which one makes an ideal choice? If yes, this post is for you. Here, you will learn everything about butcher block vs granite – Pros and Cons to make an informed decision.
For further details about kitchen countertops, visit
Butcher block countertops: The pros
The following are the pros of Butcher Block Countertops:
1. You can slice and dice directly on countertops made with butcher block:
In the series of butcher block countertops vs granite, the ability to prepare food directly on the butcher block surface is the biggest advantage to the homeowners. These surfaces may eliminate the requirement of a chopping board. Additionally, the remaining bits and stains can be cleaned easily.
2. Butcher block countertops provide you with a quieter kitchen:
If you place something on the countertops made with natural stones like granite, it will certainly make a “clinging” sound. Now imagine if you have a kid at home, he will tend to keep utensils on the surface, and you can’t stop the noise. However, a butcher block countertop will be a blessing in this scenario.
3. Simple and quick to refinish:
Let’s face it; every surface will require some sort of cleaning and refinishing. Natural stone countertops like granite aren’t easy to work within such cases. However, refinishing the butcher block is a quick job. All you require is fine-grit sandpaper to get rid of the scratches and dullness and some re-oiling to give it a perfect finish at the end.
4. Pocket-friendly:
In comparison to granite, butcher block countertops are easier on your pocket. Butcher block can be the best bet for homeowners looking for a cost-effective countertop option.
Butcher block countertops: The cons
With some pros, butcher blocks have some cons as well:
1. Unfinished wood can retain moisture:
For beginners, it is important to know that unfinished wood can be porous. It can be the home to moisture as well as bacteria. So, if the wood of your countertop absorbs liquid, it can lead to warping. Hence, your butcher block countertop may appear too blunt over time.
2. High maintenance:
People who are seeking information on butcher block countertops vs granite are particularly concerned about the maintenance requirements. Wood countertops for the kitchen need much more care than the granite ones. For instance, keeping the butcher block countertop clean and dry after every use is necessary to prevent dampness and cross-contamination.
3. Dust accumulation:
Dust and food crumbs are more visible on the butcher block countertops than on other stone-based surfaces. Therefore, you need to make efforts to keep it clean.
4. Dries out:
Like any other wooden surface, butcher block countertops can dry out in some time. Hence, there is a need to apply a thin coat of oil (food grade) to help prevent the butcher block from drying out.
Granite Countertops: The pros
Here is a list of the benefits of granite countertops:
1. Appearance:
In the Butcher block vs granite contest, people are majorly concerned about the look and feel that countertops can introduce into their kitchens. In terms of appearance, granite countertops are a clear winner. And, the reason is simple, you can choose granite countertops in a wide range of colors and patterns.
Since no two stones look the same due to their different mineral formation, each granite countertop is unique, and it is the key reason behind the popularity of granite among homeowners.
2. Granite countertops are durable:
Unlike butcher blocks, granite surfaces don’t get scratched easily. However, granite can be counted on as a scratch-resistant material but doesn’t mean it is completely scratch-proof. Therefore, you need to be careful when it comes to placing sharp objects on it. Additionally, you should avoid using knives to chop vegetables directly on granite surfaces.
Furthermore, sealed granite countertops are non-porous. They won’t absorb water and moisture, which ultimately increases their durability.
3. Fire resistance:
Since granite is a stone, it has a high level of fire resistance. On the other hand, butcher block countertops can catch fire easily as they are made of wood.
4. Natural material:
If you want to buy a long-lasting kitchen countertop made of natural material and non-porous, then granite can be an ideal choice.
Granite countertops: The cons
Explore some cons that come with granite countertops:
1. Breakable:
The granite countertops are breakable, so the stone might get chipped if you accidentally drop a heavy object on the corner. Therefore, you need to be extra careful.
2. Hard to repair:
If there is a crack on your granite countertop, then either it will be hard to repair or can be an expensive affair for you. Moreover, you might need to replace the countertop in extreme damage cases entirely.
3. Prone to fading:
The charm and sheen of granite countertops may fade away over some time. In fact, you may face the issue of granite discoloration sooner if it is exposed to the sunlight. So, if you want to install a granite countertop in an outdoor area, always ensure that the surface is covered when not in use.
4. May cause damage on removal:
If you fix the granite to the cabinets in your kitchen, it can not be removed easily and may badly damage the cabinets.
Butcher block vs granite: Who wins the debate?
Since both the materials have their own advantages and disadvantages, there can’t be a right or wrong answer. The choice entirely depends on your particular requirements, budget, and preferences.
Butcher block comes with food preparation convenience and is easy on the pocket. On the other hand, granite offers the perks such as durability, fire, and scratch resistance.
We’re sure, our post on butcher block countertop vs granite: pros and cons will help you pick the best countertop surface for your kitchen.
Comments